Simple Mobile vs. Tracfone: Which Carrier is Better?

If you’re looking for budget-friendly cell phone plans, Simple Mobile vs. Tracfone is a matchup you’ll want to check out. Simple Mobile rides on T-Mobile’s blazing-fast network, offering great coverage and unlimited data options for those who need reliable cell phone service. Tracfone, on the other hand, gives you the flexibility to choose between Verizon, AT&T, and T-Mobile networks, ensuring you get the best coverage in your area. Ready to find out which carrier gives you the best value? Let’s dive into the details!

Here’s what we’ll explore:

• A side-by-side comparison of coverage to see how each carrier measures up
• A breakdown of pricing and data plans to help you find the best deal
• A look at the features and perks each carrier brings to the table

Compare Tracfone to other Mobile Virtual Network Operator Carriers

• Switching to a prepaid carrier like Visible, a Verizon-owned MVNO, provides affordable unlimited data plans with reliable nationwide coverage.
• Straight Talk, a Verizon-owned MVNO, offers affordable prepaid plans with nationwide coverage.
• Mint Mobile, a T-Mobile MVNO, delivers affordable prepaid plans with nationwide 5G coverage, ideal for budget-conscious users.

Simple Mobile Overview

Simple Mobile's customer service options, plan prices, phone selection, and network performance make it a cost-effective carrier that operates on T-Mobile’s network, offering affordable low- and mid-tier data plans nationwide. With a range of plans, enticing new customer offers, and multi-line discounts, it provides excellent value for those seeking an MVNO. Customers can enjoy additional perks such as a 15% student discount, Autopay savings, and extra hotspot data on unlimited plans. Streaming is available up to 480p in SD, and the plans also include talk and roaming data for both Mexico and Canada, along with international roaming services.

TracFone Overview

TracFone, an MVNO owned by Verizon, offers budget-friendly phone plans that utilize all three major U.S. networks. With access to 5G, TracFone ensures fast and reliable coverage by connecting to the strongest network available in your area. Designed for cost-conscious users, TracFone provides affordable plans with limited data, rather than unlimited options. By tapping into the extensive reach of Verizon, T-Mobile, and AT&T, TracFone guarantees nationwide 5G coverage for its customers.

Simple Mobile Coverage

Simple Mobile's customer service options include contacting representatives via phone or online chat, and it runs on T-Mobile’s 5G and 4G LTE networks, delivering reliable coverage across almost all states. With this partnership, Simple Mobile users enjoy solid service, especially as T-Mobile’s expanding 5G network is set to cover over 90% of the country in the near future. While this goal is still in progress, Simple Mobile users already experience great coverage, particularly in urban and suburban areas. To check coverage in your area, you can refer to Simple Mobile’s coverage map.

TracFone Coverage

TracFone, an MVNO, leverages the networks of Verizon, T-Mobile, and AT&T to provide a wide range of coverage options. While T-Mobile offers strong 5G coverage in urban areas, it may have some limitations in rural regions. To help customers find the best network for their needs, TracFone’s coverage map shows tower locations and details on which network controls them. This flexibility ensures that users can enjoy more reliable coverage based on their specific location.

Network Coverage Comparison

Simple Mobile offers coverage powered by T-Mobile’s 5G and 4G LTE networks, providing excellent service across urban and suburban areas. While T-Mobile’s 5G network is still expanding, Simple Mobile users can expect reliable and fast connectivity, especially in areas where 5G coverage is available.

Tracfone, on the other hand, utilizes Verizon, T-Mobile, and AT&T networks, ensuring broader nationwide coverage. However, Tracfone doesn’t allow you to choose your preferred network, which means your coverage may vary depending on the area.

In short, Simple Mobile provides coverage through T-Mobile’s expanding 5G network, while Tracfone offers broad coverage through multiple networks, offering reliable service across the country.

Simple Mobile Unlimited Data Plans

Truly Unlimited + 15GB Hotspot

This plan offers unlimited high-speed data up to 40GB each month, after which speeds drop to 2G. It also includes 15GB of mobile hotspot data, which slows once the cap is reached. With the Autopay discount, you get 55GB for $1.09 per GB at full price. Cost: $60/month ($57 with Autopay) Pros: Includes hotspot data Cons: Speeds slow after 40GB Best for: Heavy data users and frequent travelers

Truly Unlimited + 5GB Hotspot

This plan provides 40GB of full-speed data, after which speeds slow to 2G. You also get 5GB of mobile hotspot data, which stops once the limit is reached. After the first 3 months, the Autopay discount drops to 5%, bringing the price to $47.50 per month.
Cost: $50/month ($45 with Autopay for the first 3 months, then $47.50)
Pros: Larger Autopay discount, separate hotspot data
Cons: Speeds slow after 40GB
Best for: Heavy data users who prefer a shorter commitment

15GB Plan

This plan provides 15GB of high-speed data, plus hotspot access. Once the cap is reached, speeds drop to 2G for both data and hotspot. It’s perfect for light to average data users.
Cost: $40/month ($37.50 with Autopay)
Pros: Includes hotspot access
Cons: Speeds slow after 15GB
Best for: Light to average data users

5GB Plan

This plan offers 5GB of high-speed data along with mobile hotspot access. Once the 5GB cap is hit, speeds drop to 2G. Ideal for light data users who still need some hotspot functionality.
Cost: $30/month ($28.50 with Autopay)
Pros: Includes hotspot access
Cons: Expensive for the amount of data
Best for: Light data users

3GB Plan

With 3GB of full-speed data and mobile hotspot access, this plan offers basic data needs. After the 3GB cap, speeds slow to 2G, making it a budget-friendly option for those with minimal data requirements.
Cost: $25/month ($23.75 with Autopay)
Pros: Includes hotspot access
Cons: Expensive for minimal data
Best for: Users with minimal data needs

Family Plan Offerings

Simple Mobile offers multi-line discounts for up to 5 lines on one account. Adding more lines increases savings, making it an affordable option for families. With these discounts, each additional line lowers the cost per line.
Best for: Families seeking multiple lines under one account with discounts.

TracFone Plans

24GB Annual Plan

TracFone's 24GB Annual Plan offers 24GB of high-speed data each month. Once the data cap is reached, speeds are throttled. This plan also includes unlimited talk and text, making it perfect for average data users. Payment is required upfront for the annual renewal.
Cost: $199 annually ($16.58/month)
Cost per GB: $0.69
Pros: 24GB of full-speed data
Cons: Data throttling after 24GB
Best for: Average data users

10GB Monthly Plan

With 10GB of high-speed data and unlimited talk and text, this plan does not include hotspot access. After reaching the cap, speeds will be reduced.
Cost: $40/month ($35 with Autopay)
Cost per GB: $4
Pros: Autopay discount
Cons: No hotspot access
Best for: Light data users

5GB Monthly Plan

The 5GB Monthly Plan offers 5GB of high-speed data with unlimited talk and text, but no hotspot access. Speeds will be reduced once the cap is hit.
Cost: $30/month ($25 with Autopay)
Cost per GB: $6
Pros: Autopay discount
Cons: No hotspot access
Best for: Light data users

3GB Monthly Plan

This plan provides 3GB of high-speed data with unlimited talk and text. There is no hotspot access, and once the cap is reached, data access will stop.
Cost: $25/month ($20 with Autopay)
Cost per GB: $8.33
Pros: Autopay discount
Cons: No hotspot access
Best for: Light data users

2GB Monthly Plan

This plan includes 2GB of data, unlimited talk and text, but no hotspot access. It’s ideal for users with minimal data needs.
Cost: $20/month ($15 with Autopay)
Cost per GB: $10
Pros: Autopay discount
Cons: No hotspot access
Best for: Light data users

750 Minutes, 1500 Texts, 2GB (3 Months)

This plan is designed for minimal talk and text users, providing 750 minutes, 1500 texts, and 2GB of data each month.
Cost: $50 for 3 months ($16.67/month)
Cost per GB: $8.33
Pros: Minimal talk and text
Cons: No Autopay
Best for: Light phone users

1500 Minutes, 1500 Texts, 1.5GB (Annual)

An annual plan offering 1500 minutes, 1500 texts, and 1.5GB of data per month. Perfect for light users.
Cost: $125 annually ($10.42/month)
Cost per GB: $6.95
Pros: Autopay discount
Cons: No hotspot access
Best for: Light phone users

750 Minutes, 1000 Texts, 1.5GB (3 Months)

The 3-month plan gives you 750 minutes, 1000 texts, and 1.5GB of data per month. No Autopay option available.
Cost: $45 for 3 months ($15/month)
Cost per GB: $10
Pros: Minimal talk and text
Cons: No Autopay
Best for: Light phone users

750 Minutes, 1000 Texts, 1GB (2 Months)

This 2-month plan offers 750 minutes, 1000 texts, and 1GB of data. No hotspot access included.
Cost: $35 for 2 months ($17.50/month)
Cost per GB: $33.25
Pros: Autopay discount
Cons: No hotspot access
Best for: Light phone users

500 Minutes, 1000 Texts, 500MB (2 Months)

TracFone’s most basic plan, providing 500 minutes, 1000 texts, and 500MB of data over two months, ideal for very light phone users.
Cost: $25 for 2 months ($12.50/month)
Cost per GB: $6.25
Pros: Autopay discount
Cons: No hotspot access
Best for: Very light phone users

500 Minutes, 500 Texts, 500MB (Monthly)

This minimal plan provides 500 minutes, 500 texts, and 500MB of data, ideal for minimal phone use.
Cost: $15/month ($14.25 with Autopay)
Cost per GB: $30
Pros: Autopay discount
Cons: No hotspot access
Best for: Minimal phone use

Talk + Text, No Data (Monthly)

For users who need only talk and text, this budget-friendly option is perfect.
Cost: $15/month ($10 with Autopay)
Pros: Autopay discount
Cons: No data
Best for: Users who only need talk and text

Family Plan Options

TracFone offers family plans with up to five lines on one account. While family plans do not offer discounts, they provide flexibility for managing multiple lines.
Cost: Starting at $30/month for the first line, $20/month for additional lines
Best for: Families seeking affordable coverage.

Plan Comparison

Simple Mobile and Tracfone both provide budget-friendly prepaid plans, but they offer different features when it comes to network coverage and data options. Simple Mobile runs on T-Mobile’s network, offering reliable 4G LTE and 5G service, with a variety of plan choices, including unlimited data plans.

Tracfone, on the other hand, uses Verizon’s network, providing solid coverage with a mix of data-limited plans, but it doesn't offer the flexibility of choosing between multiple networks. Simple Mobile’s plans start at $25 per month, offering both data and talk/text, while Tracfone’s plans range from $10 for basic service to $40 for plans with higher data limits.

Simple Mobile is best for users who prefer T-Mobile’s 5G network and want flexible data options, while Tracfone is more suitable for those who need reliable Verizon coverage at an affordable price.

Key Differences Between Red Pocket Mobile and Tracfone

Data Speeds, Prioritization, and Throttling

Simple Mobile provides unlimited data plans on T-Mobile’s network, but once users exceed 35GB of high-speed data in a month, they may experience temporary slowdowns due to data deprioritization, particularly in areas with high network congestion. While speeds will be reduced during these peak times, they return to normal once the congestion clears. Simple Mobile does not implement permanent throttling, meaning the service is a solid choice for light to moderate users, though heavy data users may encounter occasional slowdowns in crowded locations.

Tracfone operates on Verizon’s network but provides a lower tier of data priority. During periods of network congestion, such as in busy cities or crowded events, Tracfone users may experience slower speeds as their access is deprioritized behind Verizon's main and higher-tier customers. In less congested areas, however, Tracfone offers high-speed data at budget-friendly prices, making it a cost-effective option to access Verizon’s coverage. That said, users should be aware that performance can vary based on location and overall network demand.

Customer Service and Accessibility

Simple Mobile operates fully online, offering customer service through chat and phone support. Their customer service representatives are available to assist through different communication channels, ensuring easy access to assistance whenever needed. Whether via chat or phone, Simple Mobile aims to provide quick and responsive support for any inquiries. For added security, users may be asked to verify they are human before accessing support.

Tracfone offers multiple convenient ways to connect with its support team, primarily through online channels. Customers can access self-service support via online chat, available daily. For those who prefer phone assistance, Tracfone also provides support during the same hours. While these options are accessible, the absence of 24/7 availability may not be ideal for customers needing assistance outside of these hours.

The Verdict

Both Simple Mobile and Tracfone offer affordable prepaid plans, but each has its own advantages.

Simple Mobile, powered by T-Mobile’s network, offers flexible plans with benefits like Autopay discounts and hotspot options, making it ideal for light to moderate data users.

Tracfone, operating on Verizon’s, T-Mobile’s, and AT&T’s networks, provides broader coverage options but lacks the same flexibility, with a focus on basic, no-frills plans for cost-conscious users.

If you’re looking for flexibility and a variety of plan options, Simple Mobile is the better choice. However, if you prefer broader network access with straightforward, budget-friendly options, Tracfone might be the right fit.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use my existing phone with Simple Mobile or Tracfone?

Yes, both Simple Mobile and Tracfone allow you to bring your own phone, provided it’s unlocked and compatible with their mobile virtual network operators. You can check if your phone is compatible by visiting Simple Mobile’s website or Tracfone’s website before making the switch. If your phone works with their network, you can easily continue using it with their prepaid carriers.

Can I switch networks between Simple Mobile and Tracfone?

Simple Mobile operates solely on T-Mobile’s network, so users can't switch between networks. Tracfone, on the other hand, offers flexibility by utilizing the Verizon network, AT&T, and T-Mobile. This allows Tracfone users to choose which network offers the best performance for their location, giving them more options compared to Simple Mobile's single-network model.

Do Simple Mobile and Tracfone offer any data rollover options?

Neither Simple Mobile nor Tracfone offers data rollover, which means any unused data will expire at the end of each billing cycle. It’s important to keep track of your data usage to make sure you’re getting the most value from your plan. These prepaid carriers offer tiered plans, so knowing how much data you need can help you avoid paying for unused service.

Are there any extra charges for international calls with Simple Mobile or Tracfone?

Both Simple Mobile and Tracfone provide international calling, but additional charges may apply depending on the destination and plan. Simple Mobile’s unlimited international calling is generally available to select countries, while Tracfone wireless offers international calling at additional rates. Always check your service offerings and the fine print on the websites to avoid unexpected charges when making international calls.

Do Simple Mobile and Tracfone offer family plan discounts?

Simple Mobile offers multiline discounts, providing savings when you add additional lines to your account. This makes it an affordable option for families. Tracfone does not offer multiline discounts but allows up to five lines on a single account. Each line is billed separately, and there are no additional savings for multiple lines. If you’re looking to save money on a family plan, Simple Mobile’s discounts may be more appealing.

‍